Beauty-Editor Empties Are Rare, But Multiple Refills Are Unheard Of—9 Skincare Picks I’ve Finished 3+ Times

As someone who introduces a brand-new skincare gem to her routine every single week (oftentimes more than one, I must admit), I rarely—like, never—polish off products. My bathroom counter is stacked with enough soon-to-be-launched stalwarts to rival the aisles of Sephora, so when I do commit to a formula until I reach the final pump, you can safely assume it’s good—really good. And when I restock said formula again and again, using it until the last drop every single time? It’s not just good; it’s pretty freaking spectacular.

That said, these A+ items are rather rare—certainly more rare than the occasional beauty-editor empty. After almost a decade in the industry, I only have nine products I consider to be immediate, non-negotiable restocks, ones I hold so dear that I’m genuinely bummed when I’m finally down to the dregs. Here, explore the current list of cult favorites I’ve flown through not once, not twice, but three (or more!) times.